jump to navigation

Stewart Vs. Cramer: Real Journalism for a Change March 15, 2009

Posted by Dwight Furrow in Current Events, Dwight Furrow's Posts.
Tags: , , , ,

Watching Jon Stewart’s take down of Jim Cramer last week was fascinating. I’m not sure what Jim Cramer thought he was getting into when he appeared on the show, but it apparently wasn’t the sober, pointed unveiling of corruption in the news business that Stewart managed to pull off.

Cramer’s “whipped puppy” act revealed the weakness of the kind of “journalism” he does. CNBC does not do investigative journalism. Their reporters ask CEO’s how their companies are doing, the CEO’s say they’re doing fine, and the “journalist” recommends the public buy their stock. The viewer is led to believe that they are getting real journalism. It is sad that it takes a fake comedy news  show to enlighten people about what is really going on.

Of course, if Cramer were a real journalist who did his job, top CEO’s would not talk to him. The reason why much journalism consists of innocuous statements and “he said, she said” reporting is because, if they really did investigations, the “very important people”  would stop taking their calls. Celebrity “journalists” are paid enormous salaries, ostensibly, to understand economics or politics. But they mistakenly think that having access to people (or their PR staff ) will give them some special insight into what is going on. The result is corruption and complicity; not journalism.

Most of what the public needs to know can be found in reports and other sources of data, tracking down and encouraging whistleblowers, and the careful scrutiny over time of what the main players do, not what they say. But that takes a lot of legwork and careful analysis over an extended period of time. Newspapers no longer have the resources to do it, and cable news, concerned only with ratings, has no incentive to do it.

I have no thoughts on how the news business should be restructured to incentivize real news gathering. But our democracy depends on finding an answer.



1. utah1234 - March 15, 2009

It is ironic that Jon Stewart and a comedy show instead of the regulators or news media had to bring all of this public. Also in Cramers defense he is far less guilty than most of the other financial media for their efforts together with Wall Street, the politicians & incompetent regulators for what has happened.

While I enjoy watching Cramer every night, one must remember the show is primarily entertainment. The financial networks exist to promote their advertisers financial and investment products. Who would expect them to warn about the credit bubble or coming Washington national debt collapse which will destroy much of the remaining private wealth in America today or what this will do to the dollar, the stock market, bonds, gold or the real estate market?

China is now worried about their dangerous over investment in US Treasury obligations. Washington ’s long-term choice is either repudiation or monetization. For monetization to be effective, the depreciation in the dollar would have to be substantial and this in turn would dramatically raise prices of imports for American consumers which would mean a tremendous drop in foreign imports. Debt monetization would cause more disruption to exporting nations than selective repudiation of Treasury debt.

The Campaign to Cancel the Washington National Debt By 12/22/2013 Constitutional Amendment is starting now in the U.S. See: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=67594690498&ref=ts


Ron with 30 plus years in the investment business and banking industry.

2. Paul Moloney - March 16, 2009

Thank God, if one can say that, for Jon Stewart.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: