What is Philosophical Expertise? November 5, 2009Posted by Dwight Furrow in Dwight Furrow's Posts, Philosophy.
Tags: Certain Doubts, epistemology
There is an interesting and important discussion going on at Certain Doubts regarding the nature of philosophical competence or expertise.
The problem arises because there have been (and still are) great philosophers whose work was clearly false and leads us away from the truth. So philosophical competence cannot consist of finding the truth about something.
So what is philosophical expertise? What qualifies someone as an expert at philosophy? (We should exclude cases of someone who is very good at reporting philosophical positions. The question under discussion involves doing philosophy, not reporting it.)
For what it is worth, my own view is that philosophical expertise involves describing logical or phenomenological relationships between concepts and developing standards for evaluating whether such concepts are true. This involves the ability to recognize and clearly express conceptual options, entailment relationships, inconsistencies, and empirical support.
The latter ability requires the help of science whose job it is to actually develop and test empirical claims. Philosophers by contrast have to recognize when those claims provide support for conceptual distinctions.
But what say you?
For political commentary by Dwight Furrow visit: www.revivingliberalism.com